Pseudodementia, malingering and revenge in Ancient Greece: Odysseus and Palamedes
A. Puy Núñez, A. Guitián Pena, J. M. Pías Peleteiro, M. Macías Arribi, J. M. Aldrey VázquezNeurosciences and History 2016;4(2):47-50
Type of article: ORIGINAL
AUTHORS
A. Puy Núñez 1, A. Guitián Pena 2, J. M. Pías Peleteiro3, M. Macías Arribi4, J. M. Aldrey Vázquez 3
1 Department of Neurology. Pontevedra Hospital Complex. Pontevedra, Spain.
2 Department of Nephrology. Virxe da Xunqueira Hospital. La Coruña. Spain.
3 Department of Neurology. University Hospital Complex of Santiago. Santiago de Compostela, Spain.
4 Department of Neurology. University Hospital Complex of Ferrol. Spain.
ABSTRACT
Background: Greco-Latin tradition is a rich source of metaphors and eponyms in medicine. In this paper, we unearth from ancient Greece one of the oldest portraits of malingering in Western literature.
Summary: The kidnapping of Helen of Troy triggered a military alliance within Greece against the Trojans. Odysseus, king of Ithaca, feigned madness in order to avoid being recruited. Palamedes, in a manoeuvre that risked the life of Odysseus’ son Telemachus, succeeded in unmasking him. Eventually, the cunning Odysseus would take revenge. We review classical texts from Greek and Roman authors concerning these mythical deeds and establish the diagnosis of malingering after excluding mimics.
Key messages: Odysseus’ attempt at deception provides one of the oldest depictions of this behaviour in written history. We suggest using the expression “Revenge on Palamedes” to define the relatively common phenomenon of retaliation against a doctor who has diagnosed malingering.
KEYWORDS
Deception, pseudodementia, factitious disorders, malingering, medicine in ancient history, medicine in literature, Greece, revenge
Neurosciences and History 2016;4(2):47-50
 |
||
|
